Cheri Speak

Are you listening?

What Caused Elliot Rodger’s Isla Vista “Day of Retribution”?

elliot-rodger-ucsb-isla-vista-baby-faced-killer

IMAGE SOURCE: UK Mirror and Facebook “Selfie”

Elliot Oliver Robertson Rodger, by his own account, “started out as a happy and blissful child, living [my] life to the fullest“. It wasn’t until puberty hit and sexual desire came calling that his world suddenly nose-dived into a world of pain and incredible angst that inevitably culminated in a bloody rampage with up to 12 different crime scenes, resulting in 7 deaths (including his own) and leaving more than a dozen people injured in Isla Vista, California near the UC Santa Barbara campus where 22-year-old Elliot was an on-again off-again student at Santa Barbara City College.

elliot-rodger-isla-vista-ucsb-shooting
IMAGE SOURCE: Google Earth

More than 13-minutes before Elliot opened fire outside of a sorority house — and before it was known he had already stabbed and killed three men, his concerned therapist contacted Elliot’s mother Lichin Rodgers. The therapist had received an extensive and detailed email from Elliot that will from here on be known as his “manifesto” although it is really a manuscript; an autobiographical accounting of his life called, “My Twisted World: The Story of Elliot Rodger.”

After speaking with the therapist, Lichin checked her son’s YouTube account and saw the once removed videos had been re-uploaded with more added. While watching “Elliot’s Day of Retribution” video and reading the first lines of the emailed “manifesto”, Lichin contacted her ex-husband Peter Rodger, Elliot’s father, and the two immediately drove to Isla Vista calling for help, requesting that authorities meet them when they arrived.

Local KEYT news anchor and reporter Joe Buttitta, was the first to release Elliot’s  “manifesto” to the public. When I asked who all had received it and how his news station had acquired it, Joe said,

The manifesto was sent to several people… his parents, an [sic] Santa Barbara Community College professor…Not sure how many were sent out. We got it from the Facebook friend that was communicating with Rodger on a bodybuilding blog [bodybuilding.com]. As far as I know they were all sent out just hours before the rampage…. most by email or Facebook we believe. “

CNN reported later that up to a “couple dozen” people had received this email.

But…It Was Too Late

Three male victims died from multiple “fatal” stab-wounds and were found in  Elliot’s Capri Apartments residence at 6598 Seville Road, APT #7, Isla Vista, CA. All three had been killed before the  therapist had contacted Elliot’s mom, Lichin. Two of the stabbing victims were his roommates whom he despised. The third victim is assumed at this time to have been a visiting friend of the two roommates. The 2-bedroom apartment only allowed for 3 residents.

In a press conference the day after the murders, Sheriff Bill Brown said,

The three male victims were apparently stabbed repeatedly with sharp objects and it was a pretty horrific crime scene.” 

elliot-rodger-stabbing-victims-isla-vista-ucsb-capri-apartments-body
IMAGE SOURCES: CapriIV.com and Victoria Sanchez, KYET

The names of all three of the stabbing victims have been released as follows: 19-year-old George Chen, 20-year-old Cheng Yuan Hong and  20-year-old Weihan Wang. Both Chen and Hong shared the apartment with Elliot. Hong is the roommate it was reported that Elliot had called the Santa Barbara County Sheriff’s Office on Jan. 15 for “stealing his candies“.

In his “manifesto” Elliot says of these roommates,

“…when the Day of Retribution came, I would have to kill my housemates to get them out of the way. If they were pleasant to live with, I would regret having to kill them, but due to their behavior I now had no regrets about such a prospect. In fact, I’d even enjoy stabbing them both to death while they slept.”

elliot-rodger-stabbing-victims-isla-vista-ucsb-capri-apartments
IMAGE SOURCE: Google

After stabbing the three males in his apartment, three more victims died from gunshot wounds during Elliot’s ruthless massacre. Those names too have been released as follows:  20-year-old Katie Cooper and 19-year-old Veronika Weiss were gunned-down across the street from the Alpha Phi sorority house; 20-year-old Christopher Michael-Martinez was hit by gunfire while inside the IV Deli Market when Elliot opened fire from his black BMW.

elliot-rodger-shooting-victims-isla-vista-ucsb
IMAGE SOURCE: Google

It is worth noting that although Elliot claimed in his YouTube videos — as well as in the “manifesto”, that he wanted to kill women specifically [especially the blonde ones] only two of victims were women; but only one of them was a blonde.

In his final chilling YouTube video titled, “Elliot Rodger’s Retribution”, he looks into the camera and tells the world,

On the day of retribution I am going to enter the hottest sorority house of UCSB and I will slaughter every single spoiled, stuck-up blond slut I see inside there.”

He used similar verbiage, although more detailed, in his “manifesto”,

Alpha Phi sorority is full of hot, beautiful blonde girls; the kind of girls I’ve always desired but was never able to have because they all look down on me. They are all spoiled, heartless, wicked bitches. They think they are superior to me, and if I ever tried to ask one on a date, they would reject me cruelly. I will sneak into their house at around 9:00 p.m. on the Day of Retribution, just before all of the partying starts, and slaughter every single one of them with my guns and knives. If I have time, I will set their whole house on fire. Then we shall see who the superior one really is!”

In the 137-page biography or “manifesto” written by Elliot over the last several months of his life, Elliot not only speaks of his desire to “shoot”, “stab” and “flay” his enemies; he also relishes the idea of running people down with his vehicle, ideally with his father’s SUV saying,

I already planned to use the Mercedes SUV as one of my weapons on the Day of Retribution, since Isla Vista on weekend nights was always filled with my enemies walking right in the middle of the road. They would be easy targets.”

The gaping hole in the shattered windshield of Elliot’s BMW Coupe is said to have been caused by the impact of a bicyclist Elliot ran down who was reported to have suffered massive head trauma. There were 6 others who Elliot ran down with his car. There is no word currently on the status of the 13 or more people who were injured by gunfire and/or vehicular assault.

elliot-rodger-crashed-bmw-isla-vista
IMAGE SOURCE: dailymail.co.uk

The Victims That Weren’t

Although Elliot’s “manifesto” claims he was also going to kill his 5-year old brother, Jazz, as well as his step-mother, actress, Soumaya Akaaboune, while his father was out-of-town and then steal his father’s SUV, Elliot at some point had a change of heart or a change of plans. It is unknown what caused him to alter his plan,

The manifesto reads,

That was the day that I decided I would have to kill him on the Day of Retribution. I will not allow the boy [Jazz}to surpass me at everything, to live the life I’ve always wanted. It’s not fair that he has the chance to have a pleasurable life while I’ve been denied it. It will be a hard thing to do, because I had really bonded with my little brother in the last year, and he respected and looked up to me. But I would have to do it. If I can’t live a pleasurable life, then neither will he! I will not let him put my legacy to shame. In order to kill Jazz, I would have to kill Soumaya too, but that will be easy. All I would need to do is think about all of the hurtful things she had said to me in that past as I plunge my knife into her neck.But what if father is in the house to stop me? Would I have to kill him too? That would be too much.”

Elliot had “set the date” for his killing spree more than once and for various reasons had postponed it. In the “manifesto” he says Saturday May 24th would definitely be the day, however even that had changed and for reasons that were only known to him, Elliot chose instead Friday, May 23rd as his, “Day of Retribution”.

It is still unknown at what time prior to the shooting spree Elliot stabbed the three men found in his apartment. According to his “manifesto”, he had planned to do this a day before what he had deemed his 2nd phase, the “War on Women”. He had also vowed to decapitate them. We won’t know the details of what went on in that apartment until autopsy reports come out. It is also at that time we will know more about what kind of “sharp objects” or knives Elliot used.

elliot-rodger-dead-body-isla-vista-ucsb-massacre
IMAGE SOURCE: AP

It is also still unknown whether the bullet to the head that killed Elliot Rodger’s was one that came from law enforcement or by one of guns. In his “manifesto” he clearly intends to take his own life. He wanted to ensure he himself did not survive and have to face authorities.

Elliot and Asperger Syndrome

Elliot Rodger was a small and awkward child; he became an even more awkward adult whose slight body still resembled that of a young teen. His small and “frail” frame was a bone of contention for Elliot his entire life, but never more so than after puberty.

elliot-rodger-mass-murderer-isla-vista-ucsb
IMAGE SOURCE: YouTube screenshot of Elliot Rodger’s video, ” Why Do Girls Hate Me So Much”

He was also of mixed-race, a Eurasian with sharp features and was not a bad-looking guy however slight. He was well-traveled from an early age and still harbored a slight accent he would sometimes exaggerate. Elliot spoke like many others with Asperger Syndrome; robotic, monotonous, stilted, which is apparent in his many videos where you hear him speaking.

Having seen multiple mental health experts off and on since he was at least 13-years old [8-years-old by some reports], Elliot Rodger had a “high-functioning” form of Asperger syndrome”according to Alan Shifman, the attorney of  Peter Rodger, assistant director of “The Hunger Games” and Elliot’s [sometimes estranged] father.

Many people — since the tragedy, have opined that Elliot suffered from a Narcissistic Personality, which at face value does indeed seem to be the case to those who have watched the many YouTube videos Elliot has filmed and posted where he looks like a spoiled, arrogant 17-year-old boy preening for the camera, but  according to the Mayo Clinic,

When you have narcissistic personality disorder, you may come across as conceited, boastful or pretentious. You often monopolize conversations.

That does not describe Elliot Rodger at all. At least not the Elliot everyone knew. In fact, Elliot was excruciatingly shy and would often sit quietly alone whenever he was in any social or otherwise public situation. He was very socially awkward, not grandiose and arrogant as seen in his videos. While he hoped and dreamed you’d say hello, Elliot Rodger wasn’t about to say it first.

Those who knew Elliot have commented that his demeanor in the videos is that of someone they didn’t know.

In addition, in his “manifesto” Elliot speaks frequently about not having accomplished anything nor having anything to make people proud of him. He felt he was a failure and was very embarrassed about it although he couldn’t understand it. Narcissistic Personalities would never speak that way or admit to shortcomings.

His obsession with women, particularly blonde women and his inability to understand why he didn’t “have one” relates to his lack of understanding beyond the literal sense. He didn’t understand what he needed to do, i.e. be more social and less awkward. Instead he manifested this as being a need to be richer and more sophisticated and even glamorous. Elliot believed money talked. Growing up in the world of entertainment it is easy to see how literal that need must have seemed to Elliot.

Asperger Syndrome can be co-morbid with other psychiatric illnesses including Obsession/Compulsion Disorder (OCD). From his writings and many videos his obsessions are clear. Obsessive behavior can also be a part of Asperger’s itself.

Although Elliot lived a more affluent and privileged life than most, his family was not “rich” by Hollywood standards and Elliot had begged his divorced mother, Lichin Rodger, on many occasions to marry a multimillionaire. He felt she owed him that much believing being rich would enable him to be more desirable to women.

elliot-rodger-soumaya-peter-rodger-hunger-games
IMAGE SOURCE: fusion.net

He had a penchant for blondes and makes no qualms that looks themselves are quite important. He wanted a “beautiful blonde woman” and was quick to point out what he felt were other’s not so attractive looks, especially other guys who seemed to be able to score with woman when he himself could not.

Elliot had devoured and treated as if a religion — for a period of time, the theories and practices put forth in the book, “The Secret” [Laws of Attraction] and later, in a similar book called, “Power of Your Subconscious Mind”, by Joseph Murphy. He believed if he could just become a young millionaire everything would be OK. His life would be grand and beautiful blonde woman would flock to him.

Using the “powers” he’d learned from these books, Elliot set out to win the Lottery, literally. He spent copious amounts of money on Lottery tickets and even — on several occasions, drove across state-lines to Arizona before Powerball had become available in California. He performed meditation rituals before and after purchasing tickets, sometimes not checking to see if he was a winner until several days had passed. 

Elliot never won the Lottery.

Those afflicted with Asperger  syndrome suffer extreme difficulty engaging with others, especially when it comes to understanding the emotions and nuances of others. What Elliot thought were the answers to his problems were merely the result of how his mind worked and as he got into the later years, those leading up to the massacre, he became very delusional, which is a symptom of psychosis. Psychotic delusions paired with his Asperger’s resulted in the Elliot we have all now know.

Characteristics of Asperger Syndrome in Adulthood

Childhood onset

Limited social relationships – social isolation

  • Few/no sustained relationships; relationships that vary from too distant to too intense

  • Awkward interaction with peers

  • Unusual egocentricity, with little concern for others or awareness of their viewpoint; little empathy or sensitivity

  • Lack of awareness of social rules; social blunders

Problems in communication

  • An odd voice, monotonous, perhaps at an unusual volume

  • Talking ‘at’ (rather than ‘to’) others, with little concern about their response

  • Superficially good language but too formal/stilted/pedantic; difficulty in catching any meaning other than the literal

  • Lack of non-verbal communicative behavior: a wooden, impassive appearance with few gestures; a poorly coordinated gaze that may avoid the other’s eyes or look through them

  • An awkward or odd posture and body language

Absorbing and narrow interests

  • Obsessively pursued interests

  • Very circumscribed interests that contribute little to a wider life, e.g. collecting facts and figures of little practical or social value

  • Unusual routines or rituals; change is often upsetting

SOURCE: Gillberg, C., Gillberg, C., Rastam, M., et al (2001) The Asperger Syndrome (and high-functioning autism) Diagnostic Interview (ASDI). A preliminary study of a new structured clinical interview. Autism557–66.

It is important to understand how Asperger Syndrome may have played a leading role not only in Elliot’s life, but also in the events that led to his murderous rampage that took 7 innocent lives and then his own.

Besides an innate link with varied co-morbidity, there is the stress of growing up with Asperger Syndrome that arises from unrecognized disability, limited achievement and a sense of failure, often revealed by an increasing contrast with more autonomous and successful siblings or peers. In addition, the syndrome distorts relationships with family and peers, who can be infuriated by the person’s self-centered insensitivity, obsessiveness and rigid inflexibility. SOURCE: Howlin, P., Goode, S., Hutton, J., et al (2004) Adult outcome for children with autism. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines45212–229.

While much has been said about Elliot’s social awkwardness as an adult, the truth is, even as a child Elliot had few friends. His mother, Lichin, often arraigned “play dates” for Elliot even well into his late teen-age years. He met what became his closest friend, James Ellis, while he was standing alone on a playground in elementary school, “kicking dust”. It was James that approached him. In the end, it was also James that walked away.

COMMUNICATION: This is often obviously abnormal, ‘conversation’ taking the form of one-sided, circumstantial lectures delivered impassively by a seemingly robotic figure with a mechanical voice … SOCIAL RELATIONSHIPS: These are one-sided, distant or even absent, rather than really reciprocal. Behind this is an unempathic objectivity that results in difficulties that range from understanding friendship (and how friends differ from acquaintances) through to making sexual relationships and grasping the rules …  INTERESTS: A key feature of Asperger syndrome is repetitive or focused activities. At their most extreme, these result in an eccentric whose life is characterised by its routine, rigid and systematic approach … SOURCE: Advances in Psychiatric Treatment

While no one is claiming Asperger’s itself is the cause of Elliot’s crimes, Marianne Kristiansson, PhD, professor of forensic psychiatry at Karolinska Institute and the head of the National Board of Forensic Medicine in Stockholm, Sweden addressed the potential role of Asperger Syndrome in 2013 mass shooting by Adam Lanza at Connecticut’s Sandy Hook Elementary School. She shares how a violent Asperger case is different than that of a typical psychopathic killer [Lanza is reported to have had Asperger Syndrome],

In these cases, it’s very, very different. The motive for the crime is different. The motive of the crime is to communicate that you yourself are very offended. Other people have treated you in a very bad way and you want revenge. You want to communicate that on a very global level to lots of people.”

According to Advances in Psychiatric Treatment, If psychosis arises in someone with Asperger Syndrome, early treatment is extremely important to their prognosis that it should not be delayed by diagnostic doubts.

Elliot’s “Friends”

Because Asperger’s affects social skills and relationships it is common for someone with Asperger’s to have a skewed view or understanding of the relationships around them versus the reality of what they may really be. As noted by experts, someone with Asperger’s can easily feel a relationship is better or worse, closer or more distant that it really is.

For instance, in Elliot’s “manifesto” he speaks often of three particular “close friends”; James Ellis, Philip Bloeser and Addison Altford. These friendships where fluid and became particularly waning in adulthood. In one way or another all three had severed their ties of “friendship” with Elliot Rodger.

In his “manifesto”, Elliot writes of the loss of his friendships with these three particular young men,

I confided everything to him [James Ellis], because I thought we were on the same page. To be betrayed in such a manner wounded me deeply, though I never admitted it to anyone. On the day of the betrayal, I thought back on our entire friendship. James Ellis was my oldest friend. I … He was a big part of my life. And now he was gone, faded away into memory. I didn’t have any friends left anymore. No friends in the entire world. I didn’t want to see Philip [Bloeser] and Addison [Altendorf] after I cried in front of them at the Getty museum. I was completely and utterly alone, in the darkest pit of despair. And in that pit I withered in agony.”

Arte Ellis told the Washington Post that his son, James, was Elliot’s “only friend” and added,

 There are so many others like Elliot. There’s a lot of really, really lonely people — people that feel left out of life and estranged. And it creates incredibly intense emotional worlds for them that are not expressed outwardly to anybody, and it can be explosive.”

James himself has not yet made a statement.

After hearing the news of what Elliot had done Philip Bloeser posted a plea for prayer on his Facebook wall:

elliot-rodger-philip-bloeser-facebook-post
IMAGE SOURCE: Philip Bloeser Facebook Wall

Later the same day, Philip posted the following on his Facebook wall:

elliot-rodger-philip-bloeser-facebook-post-2
IMAGE SOURCE: Philip Bloeser Facebook Wall

In a Facebook private message exchange with me, Philip Bloeser said,

Everyone is trying to twist the real story. I appreciate you reaching out. Many spammers have been trying to contact me. Right now, every major news network in the country has tried contacting me. I did not stay in regular contact with Elliot. I kept a healthy distance from him because I knew he was socially awkward. But there was no indication that he was violent. He hid his plan from everyone. I am deeply disturbed by what happened with Elliot. “

Addison Altendorf disabled his Facebook account within 2-days of Elliot’s crimes. It can be assumed, he too is being bombarded by press, especially in light of Elliot’s claim in his “manifesto” that he believed in the fall of 2013 Addison knew he was up to something bad,

When we arrived at a beach park in Palos Verdes that overlooked the ocean, Philip had fallen asleep, so it was just me and Addison who went out to walk around. I took an instant liking to the place, and explored it as much as I could, even though I was still limping with my cane. As the two of us looked up at the stars, we had a few insightful conversations. Addison told me more about his experiences among the popular kids of Malibu, in which I still envied him greatly for. I told him about all of my newfound philosophical views regarding women, and how I believe they are mentally flawed and need to be contained. He didn’t show any hint of how he felt about this. Addison told me that I was a person of high intelligence, and that I shouldn’t waste it by doing something ‘rash’. I believe he had a suspicion that I was indeed planning on massacring my enemies and then killing myself. Of course he would have that suspicion… In a way I think he knew me better than anyone elseI am indeed an intelligent person, but the cruelty of this world gives me no choice but to exact my Retribution. I tactfully told Addison that I had no intentions of “doing anything stupid. That was my last conversation with him. It was also the last time I ever saw Philip and Addison.”

That last visit with Philip and Addison was around the same time Elliot had seen his psychiatrist, Dr. Charles Sophy, for the last time.

Sadly, because of Elliot’s skewed assessment of  “close friends”, several people listed in his “manifesto” have been plunged unwittingly into this bloody spotlight by default. Even sadder, to Elliot, these were his very best friends.

Elliot Rodger Legally Acquired His Weapons

Beginning his transformation into a cold-blooded psychotic killer, Elliot went to his first shooting range in Oxnard, California on September 12, 2012 and in his “manifesto” describes his experience as this,

I had the knowledge, in the back of my mind, that the Day of Retribution was very possible now. Going to the shooting range while I waited for my laptop gave me the perfect opportunity to gain some initial training in shooting guns, which will be the main weapons I use as vengeance against my enemies when the Day of Retribution ultimately comes to pass. I walked into the range, rented a handgun from the ugly old redneck cashier, and started to practice shooting at paper targets. As I fired my first few rounds, I felt so sick to the stomach. I questioned my whole life, and I looked at the gun in front of me and asked myself ‘What am I doing here? How could things have led to this?’ I couldn’t believe my life was actually turning out this way. There I was, practicing shooting with real guns because I had a plan to carry out a massacre. Why did things have to be this way, I silently questioned myself as I looked at the handgun I was holding in front of me. I paid my fee and left the range within minutes, feeling as if I was going to be sick.”

Less than 3-months later, towards the end of November, Elliot was convinced he had no other option than to begin planning his “Day of Retribution” so he purchased the first of his 3 handguns at Goleta Gun and Supply. It was a Glock 34 semiautomatic pistol for which he paid $700.  His waiting period was over by mid-December and in his “manifesto” Elliot speaks of the power he felt in bringing it home,

After I picked up the handgun, I brought it back to my room and felt a new sense of power. I was now armed. Who’s the alpha male now, bitches [emphasis is Elliot's]?”

In a few short months, Elliot made his second legal gun purchase; a Sig Sauer P226 for $1100. He was into serious planning mode now, but in his screed admits,

The Day of Retribution had always been in the back of my mind as a final solution if all else failed in my life, ever since I had moved to Santa Barbara.”

By the beginning of 2014 Elliot had two semi-automatic handguns and a date to wreak havoc on Isla Vista. He says in his manifesto,

I needed to buy a third handgun, just in case one of them jams. I needed two working handguns at the same time, as that was how I planned to commit suicide; with two simultaneous shots to the head. I also needed to buy magazine clips and ammunition, as well as knives and carrying cases for my equipment.”

In his mind, he neglected to consider he would be shot in the middle of his deadly rampage and lays out the exact plan he had concocted to end his own life after he took the lives of all those he had deemed hedonistic and worthy of death. He thought he would have time to drive away and find a quiet place to take his life and he wanted to be sure what he did was effective,

To end my life, I will quickly swallow all of the Xanax and Vicodin pills I have left, along with an ample amount of hard liquor. Immediately after imbibing this mixture, I will shoot myself in the head with two of my handguns simultaneously. If the gunshots don’t kill me, the deadly drug mixture eventually will. I will not suffer being captured and sent to prison.”

elliot-rodger-weapons-guns

IMAGE SOURCE: scallywagandvagabond.com

We debate often on gun laws and mental health these days, however a very mentally ill Elliot Rodger — although coming from an anti-gun family, was able to legally purchase and register three semi-automatic handguns in his own name without question.

About a week before the April date he had set to deliver his “retribution”, Elliot uploaded several videos to YouTube which were later seen by his mother Lichin. According to Simon Astaire — a Rodger’s family friend and media adviser, Lichin contacted Elliot’s therapist out of concern when she discovered her son’s videos that spoke of suicide and killing people on YouTube. The therapist contacted mental health crisis experts who referred the case to the local authorities.

On April 30, a week after Elliot had uploaded these videos, he was surprised [and scared] to find 6 law enforcement officers at his door and writes of this saying,

As soon as I saw those cops, the biggest fear I had ever felt in my life overcame me. I had the striking and devastating fear that someone had somehow discovered what I was planning to do, and reported me for it. If that was the case, the police would have searched my room, found all of my guns and weapons, along with my writings about what I plan to do with them. I would have been thrown in jail, denied of the chance to exact revenge on my enemies. I can’t imagine a hell darker than that. Thankfully, that wasn’t the case, but it was so close. Apparently, someone saw my videos and became instantly suspicious of me. They called some sort of health agency, who called the police to check up on me. The police told me it was my mother who called them, but my mother told me it was the health agency. My mother had watched the videos and was very disturbed by them. I don’t suppose I’ll ever know the full truth of who called the police on me. The police interrogated me outside for a few minutes, asking me if I had suicidal thoughts. I tactfully told them that it was all a misunderstanding, and they finally left. If they had demanded to search my room… That would have ended everything. For a few horrible seconds I thought it was all over. When they left, the biggest wave of relief swept over me. It was so scary.”

Santa Barbara County Sheriff Bill Brown said officers had found him to be, “quiet and timid, polite and courteous” when they arrived. He spoke of this incident Sunday, May 25, only 2-days after the massacre, on CBS’s “Face the Nation” saying,

He was able to make a very convincing story that there was no problem, that he wasn’t going to hurt himself or anyone else, and he just didn’t meet the criteria for any further intervention at that point. Obviously, we certainly wish that we could turn the clock back and change some things, but at the time the deputies interacted with him, he was able to convince them that he was okay.”

sheriff-brown-santa-barbara-elliot-rodger-massacre

Brown added it was “determined he [Elliot] did not meet the criteria for an involuntary hold.”

And, from a Washington Post article,

Sgt. Mark Williams of the sheriff’s office defended the deputies, saying the law would not have allowed them to confiscate Rodger’s guns unless he had documented mental-health problems or a record of violence.

How can someone who had been in and out of psychiatry for nearly 10-years [or more] not have documentation of a “mental health history”?

At the very least we know…

Elliot had been to see his old psychologist Dr. Randy Gold on the afternoon of Halloween 2012. At that time, Elliot was already formulating his idea for his “final retribution” and had actually wanted it to commence the following year on the same day.

Elliot had also been seen over the 2012/2013 winter break by his established psychiatrist, Dr. Charles Sophy, and again by Dr. Sophy in the summer of 2013. It was at that time when he was assigned a weekly “social skills” counselor, but Elliot’s plans were well under way.

In late August of 2013, Elliot again saw Dr. Sophy, this time the whole family was in on the meeting, including Elliot’s step-mother Soumaya. Elliot talks of this meeting in his “manifesto”,

Dr. Sophy ended up giving me the same useless advice that every other psychiatrist, psychologist, and counsellor had given me in the past. I don’t know why my parents wasted money on therapy, as it will never help me in my struggle against such a cruel and unjust world. The doctor ended up dismissing it by prescribing me a controversial medication, Risperidone. After researching this medication, I found that it was the absolute wrong thing for me to take. I refused to take it, and I never saw Dr. Sophy again after that.”

According to the National Library of Medicine, Risperidone is used for:

Risperidone is used to treat the symptoms of schizophrenia (a mental illness that causes disturbed or unusual thinking, loss of interest in life, and strong or inappropriate emotions) in adults and teenagers 13 years of age and older. It is also used to treat episodes of mania (frenzied, abnormally excited, or irritated mood) or mixed episodes (symptoms of mania and depression that happen together) in adults and in teenagers and children 10 years of age and older with bipolar disorder (manic depressive disorder; a disease that causes episodes of depression, episodes of mania, and other abnormal moods). Risperidone is also used to treat behavior problems such as aggression, self-injury, and sudden mood changes in teenagers and children 5 to 16 years of age who have autism (a condition that causes repetitive behavior, difficulty interacting with others, and problems with communication). Risperidone is in a class of medications called atypical antipsychotics. It works by changing the activity of certain natural substances in the brain.

Because Elliot had threatened his own life and that of others in those April videos there was probable cause for 72-hour metal health hold. By all intents and purposes Elliot’s family, therapist and the ensuing mental health experts that were called all had done the right thing, but it was the Santa Barbara Sheriffs that let him slip through the cracks.

It seems clear there is indeed plenty of documentation of Elliot’s “mental health history” and when you combine that with the nature of the video content for which the cops had been called, one would think the authorities would have done more than stand outside the door chit-chatting.  Had they taken his video messages more seriously, looked into his mental health history and entered the apartment for a safety-check they may have discovered 3 semi-automatic handguns, more than 400 rounds of ammo, knives and the working draft of his “manifesto”. The Isla Vista Massacre by the baby-faced killer may have never happened.

Sgt. Mark Williams of the sheriff’s office is quoted in that same Washington Post piece as saying,

He had some emotional trouble. He was upset. We all get upset sometimes. . . . We have to have a pretty strong belief to take someone’s rights away — the right to bear arms, the freedom.”

It is unclear why Sgt. Williams mentioned a “right to bear arms” unless they had [in April] run a check and discovered Elliot Rodger was a registered gun owner. If they did, then why would they have been so casual after knocking on his door?

Until the time came that Elliot had actually used them, no one, but the shop owners who sold them, knew Elliot had a gun…let alone 3 of them.

Are politics — personal or otherwise, already playing a role in the investigation and aftermath of this tragedy? Is that why Sgt. Mark Williams mentioned Elliot’s “right to bear arms”? This writer can see no other reason why.

While the gun debate rages on with both sides having valid points, it is still only a debate of vitriol while in reality nothing is being done to stop gun violence in America. The NRA, with all of their power and Lobbying money, may not be responsible for the acts themselves, but their rigidity and unwillingness to change is a part of what allowed Elliot Rodger to be able to legally buy the guns that killed 4 people and injured 7 others.

Had Elliot had to wield a knife down the streets of Isla Vista he would have harmed far fewer people and been stopped much sooner. Those who have opined that if one of the college students had been carrying a gun themselves this would have been over quickly, but the reality is, even with multiple law enforcement on the scene engaged in 2 shoot-outs with Elliot Rodger there was more carnage before the chaos ended.

elliot-rodger-crime-scene-map-isla-vista

IMAGE SOURCE: nydailynews.com

Would Elliot have gotten the help he needed had the Sheriffs investigated thoroughly in April? Could or would this tragedy have been averted?

We will never know, but we do know Santa Barbara Sheriffs had three separate encounters with Elliot in the 10-months leading to the massacre. One of the occasions was after Elliot had been beaten and pushed off of the 10-foot ledge he himself was trying to shove the women over.

In Closing…

There is no doubt that many other things contributed in the making of the baby-faced killer of Isla Vista. From Elliot’s broken home and constant moving, to a spoiled life that encouraged his obsessions; from the violence of World of Warcraft and Halo to the blatant in-your-face  sexuality everywhere you go and in everything you see.  We live in a world of excesses where morals and boundaries are blurred and violence is sold. The impact on those who struggle with mental health  continues to be harsh and measurable.

Access to guns is always going to be an issue and it’s an issue we need to stop debating and start addressing. There are more Elliot Rodger’s, Adam Lanza’s and James Holmes’ among us and many more whose seeds of delusion have yet to take root. Mental health cannot be addressed by ignoring.

Elliot’s YouTube channel

*

Get More Information on Natural Remedies for Asperger’s Syndrome

*
Elliot’s Other Victims: Philip Bloeser Talks Intimately About Elliot Rodger the Isla Vista Killer – PART 1 of 3

58 comments on “What Caused Elliot Rodger’s Isla Vista “Day of Retribution”?

  1. Henrietta Handy
    May 27, 2014

    This entire scenario is sad. Thank you for writing this. I do not feel sorry for Elliot Rodger, though. After reading the manifesto and this article, I am convinced more than ever he knew what he was doing was wrong, but that it was OK for him because he was Elliot Rodger. Does anyone know what causes the Asberger’s Syndrome?

    Like

    • Riversong
      May 31, 2014

      One of the almost universal elements of these rampage killing events is that the perpetrator honestly believes they are correcting a terrible wrong and engaging in justice.

      Like

  2. ajmacdonaldjr
    May 27, 2014

    I don’t think his mental health was an issue. I think his pride, envy, lust, and wrath got the best of him. “The Seven Deadly Sins: Jewish, Christian, and Classical Reflections on Human Psychology” – http://www.amazon.com/Seven-Deadly-Sins-Reflections-Psychology/dp/0195119452 You may want to watch the film “Minority Report” because it shows how murders can be stopped before they occur. Imagine if the police had the ability to scan people for anger and murderous thoughts? Perhaps they could prevent future murders. “Precrime! It works!” Minority Report 2 – Pre Crime: http://youtu.be/qR7JUUv2T4s via @YouTube

    Like

    • Cheri
      May 27, 2014

      sadly AJ…the things you mention….”pride, envy, lust, and wrath”…can be a part of mental health. Let’s not forget I personally struggle with mental health every day of my life. I would have for any pre-crime scans like in minority report (yes I have seen it lol) … I can tell you this though, which most people do not know….did you know that in the case of sexually deviant behavior…it CAN be seen in an mri? It is true and the results show up in the frontal lobe. I came across it while researching regarding to mri’s and bipolar.

      Like

      • ajmacdonaldjr
        May 31, 2014

        I think stress is a factor too. It tends to cause people to boil over… especially men. Men have a bad reputation for being the ones who want to kill anyone they can’t have so no one can have them. This guy had the small man syndrome too, which aggravated everything. As for MRI, it’s hard to tell what is cause and what is effect. The MRI could show an effect as opposed to a cause.

        Like

    • Hopefully this is meant to be satirical …

      Like

      • Cheri
        May 28, 2014

        What? The comment…or the article?

        Like

  3. bertuzzibunny
    May 27, 2014

    It’s very sad. I do feel, having read the Manfesto, that this young man was badly let down, in particular by his father. On one occasion Elliot had a broken leg, due to a fight he’d started, and his mother was leaving the country for a week. His stepmother would not allow him to stay in their home, with which his father concurred. Elliot spent a week alone in a hotel with his injury. This is just one example of something which increased his isolation and anger. Over indulged by his mother and largely ignored by his father, a very sad story for those whose lives he ruined.

    Like

    • Cheri
      May 27, 2014

      Yes I agree. What Elliot did is wrong and inexcusable…but I can sadly see exactly how this came to be. :(

      Like

  4. Adam Wood
    May 27, 2014

    Minor issue here, but potentially a linchpin:

    “Because Elliot had threatened his own life and that of others in those April videos there was probable cause for 72-hour metal health hold. By all intents and purposes Elliot’s family, therapist and the ensuing mental health experts that were called all had done the right thing, but it was the Santa Barbara Sheriffs that let him slip through the cracks.”

    We don’t know for a fact that the SBSD ever actually SAW the videos in question. We know that they responded to a call, but to date, I’ve not seen any statement from them or any other evidence to indicate that they ever actually saw the videos. Should they have? Probably. But it’s entirely possible that the content of the actual videos never actually made it through the pipeline to the SBSD.

    I don’t hold SBSD harmless here. They SHOULD HAVE followed through more than just basically making a courtesy call. But they’re certainly not all alone in their blame, either. If the mother was disturbed enough about the videos, then she should have gotten her butt (or gotten her ex or the step-mother) in the car and driven up to Santa Barbara and MET WITH the SBSD and should have gone with them to his apartment.

    Furthermore, mom and dad were FAAARRRR too permissive here, and almost certainly had to know that he had purchased guns. Based upon your post here, he spent $1800 in a couple of months on weapons alone. He also had a ton of extra magazines according to news reports, which are not inexpensive, and at least 500 rounds of ammo, which is several hundred more dollars. At a bare minimum, he managed to spend $3000 in the span of less than a year on guns, ammo, and magazines. Howinahell did his parents NOT see that money getting spent? Elliot never had a job in his life; he lived solely on the good graces (read: pocketbook) of his parents. If he paid cash, then the parents REALLY needed to wonder where three grand went for a college student. If he spent the money on credit cards, then they DEFINITELY should have noticed charges from gun stores.

    Like

    • Cheri
      May 27, 2014

      The SB Sheriffs did NOT watch the videos however the videos are exactly WHY they got the call.

      As for Mom and Dad knowing he bought guns, they absolutely did not know. Elliot was of age and purchased them secretly. NO ONE knew he had them. As for the money itself, if you did some fact checking Adam, you would discover it was saved money from birthday and Christmas gifts from out of country fam members as well as those in the States. he did NOT use credit cards. How can you opine and questions facts and real research when you have no idea what the facts are? He also BTW spent well over $2K on Lottery tickets over the past year and a half.

      Like

    • Cheri
      May 27, 2014

      BTW, again, you need to do some fact checking…the family was very concerned…Elliot was in psychiatric care for over a decade and at the time of the massacre was seeing not one, but two mental health therapists.

      Like

      • ecstasyrapture
        June 6, 2014

        Fact checking is important, very important, but so are opinions because they can be formulated on empirical and antidotal experience. Although the police are an integral component to a communities safety and service there-of, you hold them far too accountable in this article. Go do a ride-along with an I.V. or S.B. police officer and see what they encounter on a daily shift; you’d be far less critical and more appreciative of their true role. Physco-analyzing individuals should be left to the (supposed) experts as they clearly missed the ‘signs’. Why wasn’t his psychologist or psychiatrist with the police on the call? Why weren’t they more ‘concerned’ then simply sounding a small bell and not an ALARM. Sorry, but imo the supposed ‘professionals’ failed miserably here.

        That said, great article!!

        Like

      • Cheri
        June 6, 2014

        I have cops in my family. I am well-aware fo what they do. The SB Sheriffs screwed up in this case. The family and mental health experts didn’t ring a small bell, they sounded the alarm, but the cops told them all was OK and there was nothing to worry about. That is not an opinion, it is a fact.

        Like

  5. Pingback: Elliot Rodger, Mental Health, and #YesAllWomen | Stuphblog

  6. Thank you for this insightful article. I have grappling with what ailed this guy as psychopathy doesn’t quite seem to fit the bill. I still think it was something alongside autism though. Unlike other people, I do feel sorry for him. From reading the manifesto it sounds like he was a deeply unhappy person and despite what he did, no one deserves to go through life being that miserable.

    Like

  7. Bethany Fuzzamajumula
    May 29, 2014

    Excellent. Very well written and researched. I’m so tired of seeing thoughtless people posting their junk diagnoses of Rodger’s problems.

    Like

  8. Cheri
    May 29, 2014
    • Phil Watson
      May 30, 2014

      My apologies for my latest allegiation of censorship.I have no problem admitting that it was a mistake.

      Strangely enough my account did only show yesterday’s comment as “awaiting moderation” after I posted the new comment.

      Feel free to either leave these 2 short comments online or just discard them, as they do not contribute to the discussion

      Like

  9. Bonnie
    May 30, 2014

    A well written article Cheri. But I keep wondering if SSRI’s don’t play a part in many of these mass murders. The one common theme among most of these killings, other than them being young males, is that most if not all were being treated with SSRI drugs. Maybe it is time for the medical profession to rethink blanket
    perscriptions for what was once considered normal adolescent behavior but has
    now become pathologized. Especially long term usage as was the case of this young man.

    Like

    • Cheri
      May 31, 2014

      Bonnie, I am an advocate against PhRMA just for the record…that being said…Elliot Rodger was NOT taking meds. He refused them.

      Like

    • Riversong
      May 31, 2014

      Of the 30+ school rampage shootings in the US since 1984, only 7 definitively involved psychiatric drugs (and not all were SSRIs).

      Elliot Rodger apparently had (and presumably was using) Xanax (Alprazolam), a benzodiazepine similar to Valium used to treat anxiety; and Vicodin (Hydrocodone/Acetaminophen), a narcotic pain reliever.

      Like

      • Cheri
        June 1, 2014

        Elliot HAD Vicodin left over from when he broke his leg last fall. He saved them, he wasn’t taking them. As for the xanax, he wasn’t taking them regularly, he had also been saving them. They were a part of his own suicide plan.

        Like

      • Riversong
        June 1, 2014

        Cheri, unless you have a source of information beyond his manifesto, that’s an assumption.

        What Elliot wrote was “To end my life, I will quickly swallow all of the Xanax and Vicodin pills I have left, along with an ample amount of hard liquor.” He said nothing about whether he was currently using them, but they are not the kind of psychoactive drugs that have been known to cause aggression or suicidal ideation.

        Like

      • Cheri
        June 3, 2014

        There’s plenty of OTR documentation out there that Elliot refused to take medications.

        Like

  10. Bonnie
    May 31, 2014

    Well that just goes to show how much bad info is out there. Can’t find the source now, but I did read somewhere that he was on medication.

    Like

  11. Riversong
    May 31, 2014

    Thank you for this well-researched and balanced perspective on this tragedy, while so many others are either leaping to simplistic conclusions or exploiting the event to push their own pet agenda.

    I have similarly offered a more nuanced take on the Isla Vista Rampage at my blog:

    The Isla Vista Rampage & The Abuse of Tragedy for Ideological Agendas

    Like

  12. Riversong
    May 31, 2014

    Sorry, but you’re wrong about the role of mass media and fantasy role-modeling games on such vulnerable youth. While the constant barrage of counterpoductive role modeling from Hollywood, TV shows, commercials and video games does not directly cause violent acting out, they are the primary templates in our culture for (dysfunctional) male (and female) roles.

    Almost every study of school rampage shootings has concluded that one of the necessary but not sufficient contributing factors are these templates. Dr. Jonathan Fast PhD, clinical social worker in the field of psychologically troubled youth, specializing in aggression, crisis response and school safety, calls such acting out “ceremonial violence” (and wrote a book by that title).

    Park Dietz, MD, PhD, MPH, forensic psychiatrist and criminologist who has consulted or testified in many of the highest profile US criminal cases including Jeffrey Dahmer, The Unabomber, the Beltway sniper attacks, and Jared Lee Loughner, calls these killers “pseudocommados”, who use their weapons and war regalia to make up for a sense of impotence and failure. That template comes directly from Hollywood and role-playing games.

    Like

  13. The tragedy of Elliot Rodger is as real as it can get. And this is clear to see by the authenticity of the witnesses and face value documented facts where the horror itself is undeniable.

    The psychiatric help given to Elliot was pathetic if we may believe what’s written in the article above. You don’t ask a troubled individual if he’s alright for sure. You detect it. And if you can’t detect it then something’s wrong in your professionalism. He needed considered therapy in both clinical as behavior psychology, that is to say on his obsession and social maladaptive communication and therapy on personal relations and sexuality.

    He was forced to contemplate a lot about his situation, that something terribly was wrong he couldn’t deny. But he was overly focused on the symptoms. To be a thinker is in itself no problem per se but combined with his life story it certainly triggered many misfortunate thought processes detrimental to people around him and himself. And he had enough mental traits to be trapped by those thought processes. Society must be vigilant not to easily fall for the 100% assurance crisis management as a responds to such events. The causes are elsewhere. And warnings have been made decades ago.

    Like

  14. Julie Rose
    June 2, 2014

    Interesting that there’s a complete opposite mental diagnosis given here : http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2014/05/the-isla-vista-shooter-suffered-from-pathological-narcissism-not-autism/371768/

    I actually agree with your beliefs though. If anything, I think Elliot shows an inferiority complex rather than narcissism in his videos.

    Like

    • Cheri
      June 3, 2014

      Great article however, they spoke with no one that knew and/or treated Elliot. This “diagnosis” is based purely on observations of the videos and the “manifesto”. ALL who knew Elliot say his demeanor in the vids and screed are nothing like anything they had ever seen or experienced of him. Elliot would barely speak. He wouldn’t look you in the eyes. He was not the articulate person we have been presented with.

      Like

  15. As I read further Elliot Rodger’s ‘manifesto’ about his encounters with therapists it is beyond belief. They weren’t helping him, neither in talking nor medicinal. I mean this one therapist telling him he had 4 girlfriends during his education years. Yea right, extremely considerate — where did this guy get his psychology degrees? I really wonder. Elliot needed to move out of this place. Move out of an area in the world where casual sex and superficial life is standard.

    Like

    • Cheri
      June 3, 2014

      You have to remember, just because Elliot said something, doesn’t mean it’s true. We do not know that Elliot himself ever did or said the things he says he did or said, let alone what others did or said. We do however, know that Elliot’s relationships with a very small handful of people were not what Elliot made them to be in his screed.

      Like

      • Would you want to admit your association with a murderer like him? Of course not. Unless he made it all up but I doubt that since Philip Bloeser confirmed himself to be a friend of Elliot. Since you sensored the first sentences of my responds above it shows you want information to concealed from your blog visitors. I would change that approach.

        Like

      • Cheri
        June 3, 2014

        No Ben…I do not allow Sandy Hook conspiracies in my comments. This is my site and my rules.

        Like

      • Cheri
        June 3, 2014

        BTW, it’s “censored” ;)

        Like

      • What do you mean by “censored” and Sandy Hook conspiracy. I believe you are conspiracy phobic cringing at the mere mention of it. It narrows your world view.

        Like

      • Cheri
        June 5, 2014

        Hardly, I am a 9/1 Truther however, not everything that happens is a false flag conspiracy and I am sick of people trying to make it so.

        Like

      • I get it. Well ok then. Fair enough :) Me neither. And I’m glad I don’t. The thing is it wasn’t the first. And won’t be the last. Especially with its success which was anticipated well beforehand to be enough fullproof and its continued successful effect in politics worldwide, well definitely in the EU for that matter where I’m located. I count that as one more reason perpetrators of such acts know the field and know the audience they are dealing with. There’s no inside or outside of ‘the know’ crowd since in between so many other factors play a part. Public ignorance just being one of them, all other interesting social science aside.

        To come back to Elliot, I believe this http://www.killology.com/print/print_onkilling.htm can help to understand his state of mind some little more. Or did I get that link from here? Oh well, it’s good reading. It’s interesting and hopegiving that there’s at least work done by this man in this field. I sent it to our national police corps because of the incident at the Jewish Museum and the likelihood of such things happening again under influence of zeitgeist and everything else. Individuals inapt to understand differences between faith, religion, people, nations, local and geopolitics. A suspect has been arrested in France during a routine drug control in a public transport bus. Such individuals are prone to be detected by informants to be used as useful idiots, but that’s another story ;)

        Like

  16. Tom Swearingen
    June 2, 2014

    Excellent article Cheri. I agree with your viewpoints and perspective completely. Having survived very similar teen years (minus the anger and hatred) I could identify with a lot that I read. It is such a shame that there wasn’t some effective intervention early on before his problems progressed to a state of psychosis. I was lucky that things changed for me somewhat late in college.

    Like

    • Cheri
      June 3, 2014

      From everything I can gather, unless the shrinks step forward and they themselves reveal something….NO ONE had ANY indication Elliot could let alone would do such a thing, or even thought about such a thing. The demeanor we see in his videos and in his so-called ‘manifesto’ is one unlike anything those who knew him had ever seen. Elliot barely spoke let alone articulately.

      Like

      • The perception, and I stress on perception, of sexual deprivation can indeed lead to anger and frustration. Add an obsessive disorder that inabilates an escape from detrimental though processes does lead to mental stepping stones that in turn augment that perception. That’s the sort of psychosis he had. One that developed over a long period of time. That’s completely something else than a clinical periodic psychosis that induces false sensory stimuli or anxieties coming out of exagerated reasoning.

        Like

      • Cheri
        June 3, 2014

        No, his psychosis was more recent.

        Like

      • Tom Swearingen
        June 6, 2014

        Too bad there are not any videos or examples of how he usually spoke or carried himself in normal life – all I’ve seen so far are verbal descriptions. It seems like I have some at least partial insight (not clinical just from experience) from my life growing up – being small, picked on, feeling like I was never wanted or included, and shy. However I didn’t have the jealously or anger feelings and fortunately my parents instilled a “if you fall off the horse get back on” mentality in me. My commonality is that I did not tell them what was going on and how miserable I was – probably for different reasons – I just was ashamed for them to think I was a failure so I would dodge their questions or make other things up. I had such a strong desire to fit in and to please my parents also that I also focused for a while on material possessions hoping that would get acceptance and I see this in his writings and videos. For me the rarely speaking in social settings and avoiding social settings was I just didn’t know what to say or how to say it – it was not a choice. I had to learn that and it still is hard. Someone may have done this although I haven’t read it yet but if someone had taken him under their wing for a long time and earlier on perhaps it may have helped him however he seemed to not want the help he was given and I know for a while when I was younger I didn’t either out of fear of being or realizing and having someone else realize I might have been a failure. Just all so sad it had to turn out the way it did. I wonder if we will see the same or similar pattern in the guy that did the Seattle shooting yesterday.

        Like

      • Cheri
        June 6, 2014

        Possibly Tom, so far…”The Seattle Times, citing an unnamed police source, reported that the suspect is from Seattle. KIRO-TV, also citing unnamed police sources, reported that the suspect “was obsessed” with the 1999 Columbine High School shootings and had even traveled to the Colorado school where two students killed 15 people and wounded 21 others.” … having obsessions is not something unique to Asbergers. And to be sure, the Isla Vista rampage is not BECAUSE of Elliot’s Aspergers.

        Like

      • Another shooting? Oh well :(

        Not following the local news here in my country I wouldn’t know how much deadly violence there is but I do remember from the times I did newspaper pages had enough articles about trials of assassins, intended murder or not. Guns are not part of our culture as in the States. Notwithstanding some many years ago there was this guy going around in the streets of my city shooting anything that looked to him like an imigrant. With rifle at hand in the centre of town. And another mental case just went into a kindergarden … he didn’t use a gun. So, whathever some might say about gun control, it doesn’t cover everything. Killer will be killers whatever their means.

        But I also believe you people up there in the US, be vigilant. You can’t allow yourself to be indifferent towards this DOH getting out of control as wel as the DoD, of which its acronym is an obvious joke. What ‘defence’ is all about is double-speak, or is it double-think? Anyway, word meanings being twisted as corporatism, thought control, militarization of police and Imerialism takes a hight and all that takes place.

        Like

  17. I reads his ‘manifesto’ completely and there were I think not more than 2 typo’s (wrong letters or missing words). What he wrote looks legit if we put it next to his video’s. That he would suffer from hallucinating imaginary friends I doubt that. He didn’t complain they were scarce. The way he describes the way those friendships came and went would have to be made up and I doubt someone with already grave implications on forming relationships would mis on that knowledge. Or at least take time to make all that up. I don’t dee anyone he involves in his ‘manifesto’ to be a smear target or being less friends than what he attributed to them. I say again he would have had the energy to concoct such a plot — an excellent story I must say because it has all the necessary elements hollywood story: peace – intrusion – instability – plot1 – nowayback – plot2 – climax – end … well something like that.

    Like

    • Cheri
      June 3, 2014

      And that is the LAST conspiracy comment from you WRT Elliot Rodger that I will allow on my wall. There is NO conspiracy in this case and if you did real research you would know that.

      Like

      • I didn’t meant it that way. I said before the Elliot Rodger incident is as real as it can get. No need to be so conspiracy phobic though. There are laws who clearly have no issue with the term ‘conspiracy’ (http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R41223.pdf). It’s factual. So I’ll repeat: “I read his ‘manifesto’ completely and there were I think not more than 2 typo’s (wrong letters or missing words). What he wrote looks legit if we put it next to his video’s.” — so what I said is that he wrote it from his own mind and that its contents corroborates with what he said in his video’s. All the rest you clearly misinterpreted. Thank you.

        Like

      • Cheri
        June 5, 2014

        OK gotchya, thanks for the explanation.

        Like

  18. ecstasyrapture
    June 7, 2014

    Cheri, how silly of me to assume that you had no perception of beat cops daily experience; my bad, please accept my apology.

    What verification do you have that Lichin was officially informed by the coppers ‘there was nothing to worry about’ ?

    Granted, in hindsight, the coppers could have been more thorough, better procedures, specialized cops with better probing skills and I’m sure a new, more detailed 10 page form will be devised, but ‘screwed up the case’ hardly. How many times a day do officers in California respond to a person possibly thinking of suicide and how many end like this?

    Moreover, if it was so serious, why didn’t either of his parents come down? And again, why was a professional mind reader not with the cops? Was it a silent alarm, as no one wanted to draw undo attention to themselves?

    When James was alarmed, scared of what his boyhood friend was whispering, his parents were oblivious? I hope you get to interview Elliot’s step-mother Soumaya.

    And nobody knew he had dropped all classes and for how many semesters? Given his life long condition that’s weak, no follow up by anyone, anyone, anyone ever, ever.

    I did say ‘great article’ and I meant it. Thorough, has an edge, has facts and most importantly it flows so well. Until you conclude with opinion, it takes the clarity to do so from the reader or at least this reader, who thinks we should focus on the mental health breakdown in the age of Google glass, zero percent interest rates and a never ending false dichotomy’s, FWIW.

    EcstasyRapture

    Like

    • Cheri
      June 7, 2014

      The cops themselves made a statement that they contacted the parents and said that. The thing is they were called specifically because of the videos, and they didn’t bother to watch them.

      Like

      • ecstasyrapture
        June 7, 2014

        I really doubt those exact words were used as I have not read that anywhere else. ‘Hey, Ms Chin nothing to worry about here’, really. More like we went to his residence and he was cooperative, yet shy and reserved, answered our questions without us believing he was going to imminently hurt himself or commit suicide. Gee, he’d been planning this for over a year and I would bet dollars to badges that his psychologist stated the same within the year, otherwise he still wouldn’t be living alone.

        However, since it was the cops third time within a year of contacting him, I can understand that more situational awareness could have been used. As for the police officers watching the videos I have also read they were not aware of them and the request came through heath welfare.

        Further, your lack of engagement in your response to me about his parents responsibilities (given a lifetime of experience with him and knowing how he shared his inner thoughts with James and having shooed Elliott off to I.V. ) seems like an unwillingness on your part to consider it further.

        There were a lot of things at play here, least of which I would blame this entire affair on 6 beat cops…

        Like

  19. Pingback: Elliot’s Other Victims: Philip Bloeser Talks Intimately About Elliot Rodger the Isla Vista Killer – PART 1 of 3 | Cheri Speak

  20. Pingback: The Tenth Leading Cause of Death in the United States | Cheri Speak

Now it's my turn to listen...

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

IT’S FREE!

You do not need to be a WordPress member to subscribe. Just enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Thank you very much for following! :)

Join 1,043 other followers

Tweet @CheriSpeak

RSS Glenn Greenwald on The Intercept

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

Sign Up Today!

boot-camps-for-bloggers

YOU ARE THE MEDIA!

BE THE MEDIA | Buy The Book!
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,043 other followers

%d bloggers like this: